Hi Tony – thanks

The Rooms actually suggested Evelyn Julia Penny. I haven’t completely dismissed this possibility – but her marriage entry states she is Pottle.

If she is a Pottle, I think she is the daughter of William and Sarah Jane Pottle.

Someone had suggested she was the daughter of William T Pottle and Patience Susannah Evely, but they are too young to be her parents – I think William T is more likely to be her brother.

However, all the other births/baptisms are there for the other children, so why is Evelyn’s not?

So maybe she is a Penn(e)y and grew up with the Pottles? Who knows and how do I prove it?

The endogamy in this country means the DNA isn’t quite so straight forward.

Very challenging!

Thank you for your reply again, and apologies for the lateness of my reply

Kind regards SEONAID

• This reply was modified 5 years, 3 months ago by genebrarian.

Hello Eric

Thank you so much for responding!

Yes I am on Ancestry and on GEDMatch.

My GEDMatch kit number is A270281. My Ancestry user name is STHL_NZ

As far as I know, my gr-grandmother was known as Evelyn. I know very little about her. I do know my Aunt was named after her.

Evelyn and James’ oldest child was Adeline b1895.

James Edward HARVEY
b. 1871, Freshwater, Carbonear, Newfoundland
d. 1909, Freshwater, Carbonear, Newfoundland
& Evelyn Julia POTTLE
b. 1872
d. 1947, Freshwater, Carbonear, Newfoundland
m. 12 June 1895, Freshwater, Newfoundland and Labrador
| Adeline HARVEY
| b. 25 August 1895, Freshwater, NL
| & Josiah ANTLE
| b. 1894, Victoria, Newfoundland
| Emma Jane HARVEY*
| b. 18 November 1896, Freshwater, Carbonear, Newfoundland
| d. 23 November 1978
| & Frederick SNOW
| b. 3 November 1892, Clown’s Cove, Freshwater, Newfoundland
| d. 2 November 1943
| m. 3 February 1915, Freshwater, Carbonear, Newfoundland
| Emma Jane HARVEY*
| b. 18 November 1896, Freshwater, Carbonear, Newfoundland
| d. 23 November 1978
| & George BUTT
| Hedley HARVEY
| b. 9 August 1898, Freshwater, Carbonear, Newfoundland
| d. 6 November 1984, Sheppey General Hospital, Sheppey, Swale, Kent, England, UK
| & Edith Stevens BOOTHER
| b. 6 March 1898, 18 Sheppey St, Sheerness ME12 1TE, UK
| d. 8 June 1940, The County Hospital, Minster, Sheppey, Kent, England UK
| m. 28 June 1919, Ss Henry & Elizabeth RC Church, Sheerness, Sheppey, Kent, England
| Elizabeth HARVEY
| b. 26 November 1899, Freshwater, Carbonear, Newfoundland
| & William CLARKE
| John William HARVEY
| b. 8 December 1901
| George HARVEY
| b. 17 July 1903, Freshwater, Carbonear, Newfoundland
| & Leanie UNKNOWN
| d. about 1965
| James Edward HARVEY
| b. 6 September 1905
| d. 1989
| Sarah HARVEY
| b. 24 January 1907, Freshwater, Carbonear, Newfoundland
| & Ephiram BUTT
| b. 12 January 1904, Freshwater, NL
| Clemence “Walter” HARVEY
| b. 19 February 1908, Freshwater, Carbonear, Newfoundland
| Julia Ann HARVEY
| b. 1 February 1910, Freshwater, Carbonear, Newfoundland
| d. 13 June 1974
| & James Henry PARSONS
| b. 22 August 1904, Salmon Cove, Newfoundland
| d. 20 November 1994
| m. 29 May 1929

Thanks again, I’d love to see your family tree too 🙂

Kind regards SEONAID